OK. I have a movie to comment on.
Scarlet Pages is a Warner Bros./First National precode film from 1930 starring the highly lauded stage star Elsie Ferguson in what was her only sound film. By the time she made this film when she was 47, she was still highly regarded but past her prime and she would retire from acting altogether after this film.
visitors can't see pics , please
register or
loginvisitors can't see pics , please
register or
login The plot of Scarlet Pages is definitely pre-code. The film opens up in 1909 where an unwed mother has left her baby at an orphanage so the newborn wouldn't starve to death. In doing so, according to the contract she signed with the orphanage's administrators, she is denied the right to ever contact her daughter again.
The movie then cuts to 1930 and the focus is on Mary Bancroft, a highly successful lawyer with political ambitions, the Hillary Clinton of her day except much nicer. A chorus girl, Nora Mason(Marian Nixon), wanted by the police for murder has come to her office to hire her. She has just killed her father. She won't say why she killed him but it turns out he was trying to ravish her and she was horrified and killed him with a gun her mother had bought after the father had physically abused her. Oh yeah, this is precode for sure! Anyway Mary, suspecting the reason behind the murder, takes up the case, and defends her. The rest is a courtroom drama.
As you can probably guess, it comes out that Nora is really Mary Bancroft's daughter and her father was only her adopted father. Whew, I bet the state censor boards breathed a sigh of relief at that! LOL There is a bit more to this story that I've purposely left out in case prospective viewers don't want everything revealed.
visitors can't see pics , please
register or
login Elsie Ferguson commands the scenes she is in and exudes self-confidence as a self-made success in an era when few women made careers in such fields that men had generally dominated. Elsie is a bit haughty and smiles a little excessively when giving her lines but that didn't really bother me. She had made a few silent films, which are now lost, beforehand but mostly kept to the stage. Marian Nixon as Nora is perpetually pouty through most of the film and overacts her more dramatic lines. She is pleasant at the very beginning and end of the film but she needed better advice. Grant Withers and John Halliday offer reliable support as Nora's boyfriend and the D.A. The best moment in the film is when the beautiful and leggy Jean Laverty, a fellow chorus girl, struts into the courtroom, sits while flashing the male jury her garter and stocking. Why haven't I've see her before? Apparently she quit movies soon afterward probably to get married.
visitors can't see pics , please
register or
loginThe film though for all its salaciousness is just ok. It definitely is stagy, and a bit slow. Within the year, Warners would be making movies much better and with a much faster pace too.
I have a bit of a bone to pick regarding the delegation of 1930 as the beginning of the pre-code era. There is quite a lot of evidence that many films had been a bit naughty for a number of years before. That is why the movie studios felt the need to create a production code in 1930. Just a thought and there is plenty of evidence to back my thesis up. Anyway, I'll give Scarlet Pages
3 stars and that may be a trifle kind but it is the only evidence left of Elsie Ferguson's career.